PHONOLOGY, NOVEMBER 2012 CHAPTER 9: ABSTRACTNESS & PSYCHOLOGICAL

PHONOLOGY, NOVEMBER 2012 CHAPTER 9: ABSTRACTNESS & PSYCHOLOGICAL

PHONOLOGY, NOVEMBER 2012 CHAPTER 9: ABSTRACTNESS & PSYCHOLOGICAL REALITY Main Topics Abstract Analysis: When Underlying Representations Surface Forms Valid motivations/evidence or limits for Abstract Analysis Empirical Data Synchronic Diachronic (Historical Linguistics)

Extra Linguistic Data Language acquisition Abstractness Underlying Representations (UR) are usually connected to their Surface Forms (SF): they appear as one form of the SF. MengMe- Men- Mem- Meny- Menj-

Meng- Abstractness Abstract Analysis refers to when the UR never shows up in the SF: X A B C Problem: How abstract can you go? Abstractness

Motivations for limiting abstractness: Restriction of distinctive features. Mental reality & language acquisition: How children acquire language & make abstract connections between SF & UR. Tutup + Consonant Deletion Mng+ Nasal Assimilation Mnutup Abstractness Motivations for limiting abstractness: Abstractness and phonemic representation: URs

usually have broader SF distributions, based on distinctive features. m- / _____[l, r, w, y, m, n, ny] = + sonorant m / __ [k,h,g,a,i] = no natural class Thus, [m] has a broader distribution. Initial Principles Limiting Abstractness 1. The UR of a morpheme must actually be pronounced as such in some SF containing the morpheme. Problem: Too restrictive in some languages. Example: Palauan. Initial vowels unstressed -> daob

m - dab dball dobl Initial Principles Limiting Abstractness 2. The UR of a morpheme must contain only segments actually pronounced as such in some related word containing the morpheme. Problem: There are some languages with examples where this doesnt happen. Example of Abstract Analysis:

Kimatuumbi Focus: Lexical class 3 prefix /mu/. Never surfaces as /mu/ Surfaces as [m], [n], [], [mw] mu m n mw Example of Abstract Analysis:

Kimatuumbi Analysis: 2 processes for nasals. Examples Prefix /-/ -> noun & adjectives class 9 Prefix /mu-/ -> second plural subjects Comparison between the phonological process of these two prefixes in comparison to lexical class 3 prefix /mu-/ Example of Abstract Analysis: Kimatuumbi

Differences between /-/ and /mu-/ 1. /-/ assimilates to place of articulation of C, while /mu-/ deletes [u], assimilates and nasalizes C (this is optional) /-/ bowaana -> m-bomwaana goloka ->-goloka /mu -/

buundike -> m-muundike or mu-buundike laabuke -> n-naabuke or mu-laabuke Example of Abstract Analysis: Kimatuumbi 2. /mu -/ + nasal consonant = deletion of [u]. Whereas /-/ + nasal consonant = deletion // -> mimina -> mimina

/mu -/ mimiine - > m-mimiine 3. /-/ assimilates and turns voiceless C into voiced, /mu-/ only assimilates, no voicing change. // tinika -> ndinika /mu-/

teleke -> nteleke Example of Abstract Analysis: Kimatuumbi 4. /-/ causes following glide to become a voiced stop, while /mu -/ changes glide to nasal. //

wikilya - > -gwikilya /mu -/ yikiti -> -ikiti 5. /-/ has no effect on vowel length, /mu-/ become [mw] and vowel is lengthened // epeesi -> -epeesi /mu-/

eleew -> mw-eeleew Example of Abstract Analysis: Kimatuumbi So what about /mu-/ class 3 noun prefix? It behaves the same way as nouns & adjectives class 9 prefix /mu-/ 1. Nasalizes voiced consonants laabuka -> n-naabuka 2. [u] deletes before following nasal mulika -> m-mulika 3. Does not voice following voiceless Cs. teleka -> n-teleka

4. Shows up as [mw] before vowels & lengthens the vowel. epuka -> mw-eepuka Thus the UR of this prefix should be /mu-/ even if it never surfaces as [mu-]. Questionable Abstract Analysis: English Chomsky & Halle (1968): dipthong [y] derives from []. Problem: does not account well for alternation, compared to Kimatuumbi analysis. Alternation is based on sets of words in which have questionable synchronic relatedness. E.g. joint-juncture, pointpuncture, boil-bullion (pg 271).

Independent evidence: Historical Restructuring Paul Kiparsky (1968): a) Absolute neutralization: distinction between phonemes in morphemes neutralized in all cases. b) Contextual neutralization: distinction between phonemes in morphemes neutralized in specific contexts. E.g. in, im, i, i = in only for this specific English prefix. Contextual neutralization more common and more real, absolute neutralization seen as constructed. Independent evidence: Historical Restructuring

Kiparsky: Historical sound change can be used as a test of abstract analysis. Case of Yiddish, language of Jewish immigrants in Germany. Picked up rule of devoicing final stem consonant from German tag -> tak (day) tagn (days) But was later lost in Northeastern Yiddish => reversal of sound change tok -> tog based on the plural togn Independent evidence: Historical Restructuring Exception:

gelt (money) did not reverse to geld. Analyis: no plural form with the voiced consonant, unlike tagn/togn. The singular form subject to devoicing rule, plural was not. In the case of tak/tok - tagn/togn, Yiddish children could abstract from the plural the UR of tag/tog which was resurfaces when devoicing rule was lost. Yiddish children never heard the UR of geld during language acquisition. Conclusions Two methods of abstract analysis has been shown: a. Domain-internal: Kimatuumbi example, based on

feature constraints. b. Domain-external: Yiddish example, based on data from historical language change and not synchronic phonological data. Conclusions Abstract analysis of URs must be motivated by: Limitations of distinctive feature theory, in the case of domain-internal analysis. Principles of child language acquisition. Explains whether the URs are plausible based on how children learn language from spoken experience.

Abstract analysis is often abstract, in the sense that it is often difficult or even impossible to truly prove the psychological reality of proposed URs.

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • CISI  Financial Products, Markets & Services Topic  Equities

    CISI Financial Products, Markets & Services Topic Equities

    ORB. Trading Systems. SETS - quotes and crosses. Not all shares are liquid enough to trade via SETS. SETSqx is for shares where the . volume of shares traded is low. It combines . periodic auctions with quotes from market...
  • Prewriting Strategies: Brainstorming for Kindergarten - 3rd Grade

    Prewriting Strategies: Brainstorming for Kindergarten - 3rd Grade

    Things I Like To Do Create a Bubble Map Example: Prompt students to create a bubble map about things they like to do. Topic Reasons Details Create a Bubble Map Example: Prompt students to create a bubble map about their...
  • 1 Thessalonians 2 - gracebiblechurchpullman.org

    1 Thessalonians 2 - gracebiblechurchpullman.org

    A paradigm is the mental perspective or frame of reference we use to interpret reality. A synonym for paradigm is worldview which is both descriptive (how things are) and proscriptive (how things should be). God is the supreme realist and...
  • The Circulatory System

    The Circulatory System

    What looks like your left on the diagram is really the patient's right. As you view the following slides: Color the arrows on the heart diagram indicating the direction of blood flow Use blue to indicate de-oxygenated blood. Use red...
  • Broadening and Line shape - Texas A&M University

    Broadening and Line shape - Texas A&M University

    Line broadening . Homogeneous . broadening and Inhomogeneous Broadening . Homogeneous . broadening . Natural Broadening(Lorentzain profile) Pressure Broadening (Lorentzain profile) Inhomogeneous. Doppler broadening. Voigt . profile. Einstein's coefficients .
  • Malvern College Briefing on GCSE Choices For entry

    Malvern College Briefing on GCSE Choices For entry

    Compulsory Subjects: Except for pupils in the twolowestFY French sets, pupils must choose at least one Modern Foreign Language or Classical Language . English as an additional language (for non-native English speakers - All non-native English speakers in the FY...
  • The Challenge: To Create More Value in All Negotiations

    The Challenge: To Create More Value in All Negotiations

    We sell speed." —Peter Lewis, Progressive "It is not the strongest of the species that survives, nor the most intelligent, but the one most responsive to change." —Charles Darwin The "HanG out" Theorem Measure/Manage: Portfolio "Strangeness"/Quality Staff Consultants Vendors Out-sourcing...
  • BRIDGE SURVEYS - Missouri

    BRIDGE SURVEYS - Missouri

    Referenced Points (Horizontal Control Points) Referenced points are set near. each end of proposed bridge. Preferably, near the top of the . stream bank on stream crossings. ... When stream bed profiles are required on confluent streams, the limits of...