Preparation for learning Think of reasons why you think people might commit suicide. Suicide Lesson Objective: To be able to identify two different approaches to suicide. Why?
Gender Individual Age Economics Race
Depression Class Uncertainty Social
Certainty Religion Stress Suicide statistics: Read over the statistics for the rate of suicide over different countries and summarise what the graphs
tell us about the rate of suicide. What information is used to decide on a verdict of suicide? http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2017330/Natasha-MacBry de-Coroner-slams-bullies-taunt-suicide-girl-15-death.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/8918628/Wales-manager-GarySpeed-found-dead.html http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/7204172.stm
Positivist and Interpretivists Positivists Interpretivists Present New Information Positivism is an approach that suggests that quantitative methods.
Positivists see human behaviour formed by social forces external to the individual. Durkheim believed that even a highly personal, private act like suicide is a product of social forces. Positivist Approach - Durkheim High Suicide Rate
Low Suicide Rate Location Family status Marital status Religion Urban areas Rural areas
No family or children Children and relatives Catholic Protestant Married Single divorced
Explanations Durkheim Durkheim used quantitative official statistics of suicide and found: oSuicide rates for any given society remained more or less constant over time. oWhen rates did change, this coincided with other
changes. For example, the rates fell during wartime, while they rose at times of economic depression and perhaps surprisingly times of rising prosperity. oDifferent societies have different rates oWithin a society, the rates varied considerably between different social groups. For example, Catholics had a lower suicide rate than Protestants, married people with children had lower rates than the single, widowed or childless, and rural dwellers
had lower rates than city dwellers. Durkheim o These patterns were evidence that suicide rates could not simply be the result of the motives of individuals. For example, the population of the city of Paris is constantly changing, and the French army too, is made up of different individuals as the years go by. Yet in both cases, Durkheim
notes, the suicide rate remains more or less constant over time. o Durkheim explains the suicide rate as the effect of social facts or forces acting upon individuals. Construct The Suicide rate: Durkheim believed that if this was a truly private act then statistics would then be expected to show a
random pattern. He therefore concluded that the cause of suicide must be outside the individual and in forces at work in society. Construct Integration
Regulation Apply Design a storyboard/flowchart based around integration and regulation that demonstrates what it is within society. Apply Look at the following articles and see if you can
decide whether this deaths are down to too much or too little integration or regulation. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2044687/Don-Lapre-dead-Arizo na-TV-pitchman-commits-suicide-cell-52m-fraud-trial.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1226693/Multi-millionaire-City-banker-c ommitted-suicide-disastrous-RBS-takeover.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2050277/Gay-15-year-old-Jamie-Hubley-c ommits-suicide-chronicling-unhappiness-online.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2083071/Syria-Suicide-bomber-killsdozens-Damascus-attack.html
Elaborate Around the table are 4 stations of information about each type of suicide. 1.In your group - you first need to transfer the information into your booklet 2. Then you are then going to make up a case study or storyboard that represents this type of suicide. You can use extra paper if you need to.
Apply Loot back at the articles which of these link to a type of suicide. Explain why. Apply Complete the task on page 7 what type of suicide explain the 7/7 bombings.
Explain why. What about these.? http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/3391871.stm What about these.? http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/bristol/7
204402.stm What about these.? http://news.bbc.co.uk/onthisday/hi/dates/stories/november/18/newsid_2 540000/2540209.stm What about these.?
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1078531/We-help-paralysed-sondie-Anguish-parents-quizzed-police-taking-crippled-rugby-player-suicide-c linic.html What about these.? http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2066812/Gary-Speed-deathrumours-Happily-married-wife-Louise-wasnt-depressed.html Suicide and type of society For Durkheim, modern societies and traditional societies differ
from one another in their levels of integration and regulation, and this means we tend to find different types of suicide for each type of society: Modern industrial societies have lower levels of integration. Individuals rights and freedoms become more important than obligations towards the group. This weakens social bonds and gives rise to egoistic suicides. Similarly, modern societies are less effective in regulating individuals because they undergo rapid social change, resulting in
anomic suicide. Traditional pre-industrial societies have higher levels of integration. The group is more important than the individual and this gives rise to altruistic suicides. Similarly, these societies regulate their members lives and impose rigidly ascribed statuses that limit individuals opportunities, and this produces fatalistic suicides. Later positivist approaches
Maurice Halbwach Gibbs and Martin He accepted Durkeims positivist approach but used more recent and reliable statistics than Durkheim. He argued that the differences between rural and urban residence were the
main reason for variations in suicide rates. Higher rates among protestants, people living alone were more a function of their urban location these groups were more likely to be found in towns, where people lead more isolated lives. Like Durkheim, they wish to make lawlike, cause and effect generalisations
and predictions. However, they argue that Durkheim did not operationalise his concept of integration (define in such a way that it can be measured). They define integration as a situation where there are stable and lasting relationships. These tend to occur when an individual has status integration compatible statuses that
do not conflict with one another e.g. when their educational and occupational statuses are similar. They predict societies where there is little status integration (where educated people are forced to take low status jobs), the suicide rate will be higher.
Elaborate: Criticisms of Durkheims theory of suicide, can you think of any? Review Write down one type of suicide on your post it note You have to get other people to explain that type of suicide to you and give an example. Then vice versa.
Preparation for Learning Write down one question based around the positivist view of suicide. You will then receive someone else's question, you then have to answer it correctly. An Interpretivist and Realist View Lesson Objective: To be able to explain an interpretivist and realist view of suicide.
Present New Information Read the following scenario. How could you discover meanings of victims suicide? What kinds of things could you do? A Recap on Interpretivist Approaches Sociology
should focus on the meanings and motives of individuals (actors). To study the social world: use qualitative methods. People
work out what something means before they react to it. Human behaviour is shaped by internal stimuli (what goes on in the mind).
Douglas and Atkinson Douglas: the social meanings of suicide Atkinson: ethnomethodology and suicide Apply Begin completing your A3 sheet of paper that will
allow you to see the key arguments surrounding positivist, interpretivists and realist. Mini Review Write down two things that Douglas suggested when referring to suicide. A Realist Approach to Suicide Taylor is a realist, staying in the middle between
positivism and interpretivism. Realism does not suggest that all social causes of phenomena need to be observable and quantifiable: events can also be caused by underlying, unobservable structures. Taylor studied suicides and attempted suicides on Londons underground and found that coroners constructed biographies. He does feel that it is possible to identify the causes of suicide.
A Realist Approach to Suicide Read the following cases think about the kind of things you would take into account when researching these stories. Try and think of 4 categories. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article1331308/Prince-Charless-friend-PaulCastle-commits-suicide-business-hitrecession.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article2059970/Vincent-Buffoni-jumped-tubetrain-longer-afford-send-children-privateschool.html
Construct Certainty Inner-directed suicide (about self and identity) Other directed suicide
(about communicating something to others) Submissive Sacrifice Thanatation
Appeal -Stability and predictability of events. Uncertainty -Change and unexpected
Apply In your group complete the following giant card sort! Apply Read the following article about suicide think about how you can explain it using: 1 2
Solutions What is a solution? Some Definitions A solution is a _____ mixture of 2 or more substances. Made of two parts: SOLVENT SOLUTES Parts of a Solution SOLUTE - the part of a solution that is being dissolved (usually...
Pluralist Democracy. No one elite person or group dominates politics. No monopoly of power. A multitude of groups /organizations influence government decision-making (unions, interest groups, activists, lobbyists, professional associations, etc.); political power is dispersed, but the average citizen does not...
What experimental findings are the basis for the 1909 model of the atom? What shortcomings in the atomic model of Ernest Rutherford led to the development of Niels Bohr's model? A friend tells you that an electron travels around an...
In medicinal chemistry, bioisosteres are chemical substituents or groups with similar physical or chemical properties which produce broadly similar biological properties to another chemical compound. In drug design, the purpose of exchanging one bioisostere for another is to enhance the...
6.9 Case Study: Random-Number Generation Random-number generation static method random from class Math Returns doubles in the range 0.0 <= x < 1.0 class Random from package java.util Can produce pseudorandom boolean, byte, float, double, int, long and Gaussian values...
[email protected] Umoja Community History Oct 2006 - Umoja I Diablo Valley College March 2007 - Umoja II Chaffey College Oct 2007 Umoja III Chabot College Summer Retreat January 2008 - BOG Recognition Umoja Consortium Four Pilot Colleges Regional Symposiums -...
Ready to download the document? Go ahead and hit continue!