Should We Treat Data as Labor? Moving Beyond "Free"

Should We Treat Data as Labor? Moving Beyond "Free"

Should We Treat Data as Labor? Moving Beyond Free E. Glen Weyl Microsoft and Princeton Competition Conference 2018 Boston University School of Law July 23, 2018 Imanol Arrieta Ibarra Diego Jimnez Hernndez Stanford Stanford

Leonard Goff Columbia Jaron Lanier Microsoft Free Services for Free Data The digital economy encompasses many of the most popular products ever. It creates surplus for end users and tech companies. Data

Services 3 The High Cost of Free Data Despite these advances, there has been backlash against tech companies. 4 An Anxious Time For Labor

Fears about future of AI and job displacement Growing inequality (Autor et al. 2017) AI and Productivity The free-data model has failed to induce the AIrevolution in productivity. 6 The High Cost of Free Data

The High Cost of Free Data Root of all of these problems is that returns to data are being treated as payments to capital rather than to labor. Data as Capital 1. Data is exhaust to be picked up by whoever is smart enough to make useful 2. AI success mostly driven by algorithms, computational power, brilliant programmers 3.

AI will flourish if there are big payoffs to entrepreneurs and innovators 4. AI will displace workers, so either they will work in other areas or we will give them a basic income now that they are useless 5. People will have to find meaning in areas of life other than work and get over themselves 6.

Individuals are happy to consent to surveillance in exchange for free stuff, so companies deserve to use their data vs. 1. Data as Labor Data created by user actions and efforts, so fruits belong first to individual contributors

2. AI is really collective human intelligence, driven by innate knowledge/data in ordinary people 3. AI will flourish if the individual contributors who make it possible have a real economic stake 4. AI is just another production technology that raises individual productivity by allowing people to amplify the value of their data

5. The value of data will support sense of meaning and digital dignity 6. Individuals on their own have little bargaining power in face of digital monopolies, must be protected by countervailing power (competition, unions or governments) How Did We Get Here?

Current status quo comes from a mix of: Prejudice (weight of precedent created by historical accidents) Privilege (entrenched interests that derive rents from the inefficient equilibrium) The internet business-model: convince users to give their data for free in exchange of a digital service. Users grew accustomed to this model. Few users are even aware of the productive value of their data or the role they play in enabling ML to target advertise them.

Recent evidence suggests significant monopsony power in online task labor markets (Dube et al (2018)). 10 Sources of Countervailing Power There are three main channels to balance out the scale: Competition

Data Labor Union Government Action 11 Recent policy developments GDPR came into effect First Data Labor Union in Holland Merkel considers data tax

12 13

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Clic para insertar título general

    Clic para insertar título general

    Setting: Secondary care departments of cardiology and psychiatry in a single centre and the surrounding community. Participants: Patients with treated depression and matched healthy controls, aged 18-55 years, without conventional acquired risk factors for CHD. ... cabe destacar que la...
  • Artificial Intelligence Overview

    Artificial Intelligence Overview

    Artificial Life Framsticks is a three-dimensional life simulation project. Both the physical structure of creatures and their control systems are evolved. Evolutionary algorithms are used with selection, crossover and mutation. Finite element methods are used for simulation. Both spontaneous and...
  • Immune System - North Thurston Public Schools

    Immune System - North Thurston Public Schools

    Immune System - Immune. Primary (non-specific) Response. First time invaders. Secondary (specific)Response. Second time invaders/Immunological memory (antibodies) Immunity-Ability to fight off infection . Antibodies. Active Immunity. Ex. Exposure/Vaccination. Passive Immunity. Ex. Breast Feeding.
  • Mont Blanc Emblem The challenge To promote the

    Mont Blanc Emblem The challenge To promote the

    Mont Blanc took a 2 week campaign on iconic and walkway screens across 6 of our high-end 'hero' sites including Bluewater, The Bullring and Liverpool One. What we did. The landscape screens were a great solution to their landscape creative...
  • FileNewTemplate


    Bring talent from across silos to the table to understand and address issues together. Be a voice for equity - ensure access for residents and groups in low-income areas. Those steps can be done to accomplish any goal, but in...
  • T H E C L I E N

    T H E C L I E N

    A&C's extensive experience in corporate finance makes us uniquely qualified to provide a first class legal service . ... (HKEx PN 21) Notification of HKEx re appointment of sponsors. ... Student feedback and survey .
  • Irony & Symbolism - Wikiwijs

    Irony & Symbolism - Wikiwijs

    Julius Caesar (Shakespeare)—in his famous oration to the crowd, Marc Anthony calls Brutus "an honorable man," knowing that Brutus was one of Caesar's assassins. In Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Harry says, "Yeah, Quirrell was a great...
  • Nutrition Services Incentive Program - Texas

    Nutrition Services Incentive Program - Texas

    Q & A Nutrition Services Incentive Program NSIP NSIP Background Provider Types Meal Types Eligibility Requirements Reporting Requirements Background Administration on Aging (AoA) provides funding to states through the NSIP. The NSIP funds are designated to buy additional meals. DADS...