A Comparison of Home Safety Education Methods to

A Comparison of Home Safety Education Methods to

A Comparison of Home Safety Education Methods to Prevent Falls: Healthcare Professional
and Self-Directed Learning
Sumandeep Saharan (Investigator), Machiko R Tomita, Ph.D. (Advisor)
Department of Rehabilitation Science, School of Public Health and Health Professions, University at Buffalo

Objectives: Home safety education by healthcare professionals (HP) to prevent falls has
evidence to be effective, but that of self-directed learning (SDL) by older adults,
themselves, is unknown1.
Methods: This study compared effects of these two educational approaches through a twogroup pretest-posttest design. Both groups used a Home Safety Self-Assessment Tool
booklet that helps users identify fall risk factors in the home, find local resources for home
modifications and useful products, and keep a log for home hazard reduction activities.
The HP intervention provided detailed education for fall prevention in participants home
while the SDL group was provided an instruction sheet regarding use of the booklet.

Procedure for Analysis
1. Chi-Square and t-test statistics for sample characteristics.
2. Paired t-test , Wilcoxon signed-rank test, and Independent t-test for pre-test and post-test,
and between SDL and HP.
3. ANCOVA for differences between SDL and HP.

Demographics and other background information, Falls Efficacy Scale, Level of Stages of
Change (Transtheoretical Model), Home Safety Self Assessment Tool (HSSAT) v3.

Mean (SD) or
Frequency (%)



74.5 (8.79)

79.3 (9.55)

t = 2.049


Male =9 (75.0%)
Female=27 (54.0%)

Male=3 (25.0%)
Female=23 (46.0%)

= 1.753


Black= 8, White= 28,
Native American= 0,
Hispanic= 0, Others= 0

Black= 10, White= 12,
Native American= 1,
Hispanic= 2, Others= 1

= 9.250


Living Status

The Transtheoretical Model of Behavior Change


1. Is there a difference between the two methods of home safety education (SDL and
education provided by HP) in reducing the fear of falling among community-dwelling
older adults with and without history of falls?

Alone= 13
With Someone= 23
No= 15, Yes= 21

Medication List

Research Questions

Figure 3: Home Hazard Reduction

Table 1: Demographics

Conclusions: Within SDL, those with previous falls removed home hazards more than nonfallers (p<.014). Therefore, SDL using the booklet was effective in raising awareness of home hazards, in general and effective for people with previous falls in actual home hazard reduction. The purpose of this study is to identify and compare the effectiveness of home safety education through SDL and home safety education provided by HP in community dwelling older adults with and without history of falls. No= 12, Yes= 24 Difference Mean (SD) or Frequency (%) Alone= 19 With Someone= 7 No= 7, Yes= 19 No= 7, Yes= 19 = 8.260 (p=.004) = 1.433 (p=.231) = .292 (p=.589) Figure 1: Change in the Level of Fear of Falling 2. Is there a difference between HPs home safety education and SDL in bringing about change of stage in Transtheoretical Model among community dwelling older adults with and without history of falls? SDL HP 3. Is there a difference between the two methods of home safety education (SDL and education provided by HP) in the number of home hazard reduction in communitydwelling older adults with and without history of falls? A two-group pretest-posttest design was used to compare two different home safety educational approaches. The time interval between pre-test and post-test was one month. Participants Data for 62 community-dwelling older adults aged 60 and above from Western New York were analyzed. Participants with cognitive impairments were not included for the study. HP HP vs SDL SDL Table 2: Ten Most Home Hazards Removal Made 1. Removed Clutter (Living Room) 6. Installed nightlight (Bedroom) 2. Removed Clutter (Bedroom) 7. Removed/rearranged furniture 3. Removed Clutter (Hallway) 8. Wearing shoes with non-skid sole 4. Removed scatter rug (Kitchen) 9. Secured rug to floor (Living Room) 5. Added bathmat (Bathroom) 10. Removed Clutter (Bathroom) The most common hazards that were recognized in the home environment included the presence of clutter in various areas, inadequate lighting, slippery bathtub, inadequate footwear, and loose rugs. At follow-up the average number of hazards were reduced to 6.8 from 9.4 in each home. At the end of the follow-up visit most of the participants significantly reduced their home hazards. But this indicates that hazards still exist. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION METHOD Study Design SDL HP Measurement Results: At follow-up, HP group reduced fear of falling (p<.01), and both groups moved up a stage in the Transtheoretical Model (p<.001). Using analysis of covariance, the two groups were similar in changes for both outcomes (p>.05). However, the HP intervention
resulted in more home hazard reductions (M=8.4, SD=6.3) than SDL (M=4.1, SD=6.2)


Figure 2: Stage in Transtheoretical Model

1. Cumming, R. G., Thomas, M., Szonyi, G., Salkeld, G., O'Neill, E., Westbury, C., &
Frampton, G. (1999). Home visits by an occupational therapist for assessment and
modification of environmental hazards: a randomized trial of falls prevention. Journal
of the American Geriatrics Society, 47(12), 1397-1402.
2. Prochaska, J. O., DiClemente, C. C., & Norcross, J. C. (1992). In search of how people
change. Applications to addictive behaviors. American Psychologist, 47(9), 1102-1114.

The type of hazards removed by the participants suggest that cost of modifications and
the ease of making the changes are important factors for their decision to make a change.
It is also evident that history of falls has an impact on the home hazards reduction. It was
found that HSSAT v.3 is an effective tool for creating awareness about the home hazards
and motivating older adults even when it is used by themselves without healthcare
professionals. However, it was useful for actual home hazard reduction only for older
adults with previous falls. Healthcare providers intervention was effective for home
hazard reduction for older adults, in general, regardless their fall history.


Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Solutions and tools to improve veterinary legislation The

    Solutions and tools to improve veterinary legislation The

    Solutions and tools to improve veterinary legislation The Donors' perspective European Commission
  • Major Schools of Economic Theory - econjchs.weebly.com

    Major Schools of Economic Theory - econjchs.weebly.com

    Introduction The word "economics" is derived from the Greek word oikonmikos which means skilled in household management. Although the word is very hold the discipline of economics is a relatively recent development. Modern economic thought emerged in the 17th and...
  • Apakah itu Enjin Gelintar?

    Apakah itu Enjin Gelintar?

    Apakah itu Enjin Gelintar? Definisi Enjin Gelintar - suatu program yang digunakan untuk mencari dan mencapai maklumat berdasarkan kepada sebutan gelintaran (search terms) yang diberi oleh pengguna. Ia membenarkan pengguna menjelajah pangkalan data yang mengandungi teks terdiri daripada berjuta-juta di...
  • Expectations - Ms Holland&#x27;s Physics Site

    Expectations - Ms Holland's Physics Site

    The cell will always give the same number of joules to each coulomb coming through. A 5 V battery will . always . give 5 J to every coulomb of electrons. Somehow it is always able to keep up. Even...
  • Jan&#x27;s Health Project

    Jan's Health Project

    As the sun's energy comes to earth, some is reflected (1) off the upper layers of the atmosphere, some bounces off a shiny surface, like snow or ice in the polar caps, and reflected back through the atmosphere (2), but...
  • Wireless Channels: Large Scale Fading (Path Loss)

    Wireless Channels: Large Scale Fading (Path Loss)

    Times New Roman Arial Default Design Wireless Channels: Large Scale Fading (Path Loss) Small-scale and large-scale fading Free Space Propagation Free Space Propagation 2-Ray model Classical 2-ray ground bounce model Reflection from smooth surface Vector addition of 2 rays Slide...
  • Chapter 15: Darwin&#x27;s Theory of Evolution

    Chapter 15: Darwin's Theory of Evolution

    Chapters 16 - 17: Darwin's Theory of Evolution & Population Genetics These plants appear to be cactus plants, but the one to the far left is a spurge, not a true cactus. Both the cactus & spurge have reduced, spiny...
  • Response to Intervention and SLD Identification The IDEA

    Response to Intervention and SLD Identification The IDEA

    Identification of SLD Researcher Roundtable on Specific Learning Disabilities SLD is a valid concept with converging evidence across indicators and methodologies SLD are disorders of learning and cognition intrinsic to the individual(s) Each disorder significantly affects a relatively narrow range...