Ethical Equilibrium - AACTE

Ethical Equilibrium - AACTE

Beyond the Obvious: The Intersection of Educator Dispositions, Ethics, and Law Troy Hutchings, Educational Testing Service David P. Thompson, The University of Texas at San Antonio AACTE Professional Development Webinar October 20, 2016 Our Case Study for Today Texas high school varsity womens basketball coach approached the freshman womens basketball coach (female, age approximately 24-25) to ask her if she and her husband would take into their home a freshman varsity star player who was having family difficulties The ruralish school district had, at the time, roughly 7350 students and one high school of about 1950 students, with a town population of about 30,000

Case Study (contd) While the coach and her husband agreed to take the player into their home, the player did not move in, as her mother moved back into the school district However, the freshman coach discussed the possibility of this arrangement with the player This conversation led to what was termed as the coachs intensely emotional and passionate feelings for the player that formed over a five month period (as per the hearing officer) (big sister/little sister) Case Study (contd)

Players step-grandfather discovered 24 letters that the coach had written the player Players cell phone records uncovered over 2,000 text messages per month, many with the coach; as well as several phone conversations lasting from 2 to 4 hours Traveling together to the state girls basketball tournament (with another coach and player), the coach and player shared a room with another player and coach at a local hotel Viewing this Case through Multiple Lenses Ethos of care lens Educator risk lens Consequence lens Contextualize/change the variables Coming to Terms with the Terms Lets Clarify the

Lexicon Personal Morality Personal values and beliefs derived from ones life experiences subjective and may/may not align with community mores. Regulations or Law Policies, statutes, and judicial activity that articulate conduct absolutes. Professional Ethics Professional ethical standards that assist practitioners within situational and systemic contexts in choosing the best course-ofaction. Professional Dispositions Agreed upon professional attitudes, values and beliefs to be held by educational practitioners. Ethical Equilibrium Frameworks to Guide Professional DecisionMaking

Clinical Judgment Considerations Dispositional Professional attitudes, Framework Regulatory Framework values and beliefs that guide decision-making Preserv ice Policies, statutes, and case law that guide (sanctionabledecisionconduct making absolutes)

Licensu re Implicit cognitive assumptions Personal Values Consideratio ns Inservi ce Risk Management Considerations Students, schooling community, self

Ethical Professional ethical standards that guide Framework decision-making Individual decisions ~ Situational contexts ~ Systemic variables Trajectory of decisionmaking Personal-professional considerations (Hutchings, T. 2016) Nexus Between Ethics and Conduct Professional Ethics Codes of Conduct Defines the

Guide DecisionMaking Mitigate Risks Protect the Profession Protect the Practitioner Vulnerabilities Nuanced & Protect Student 1000s of Daily Complex Multiple Welfare Decisions Emotional & Stakeholders Acting in Power Intellectual the Public Absolutism

Intimacy Interest Competing In loco parentis / Agents of the Tensions State Operate within the gray . Navigate the gray . Embrace the gray Boundary Possible Sanctions Lowest Standard of Acceptable Behavior (Hutchings, T. 2016) Current Qualitative Research

52% of the participants ethical dilemmas fit into category of: Caring for others and adhering to formal Shapira-Lishinsky, O. (2009). Towards professionalism: ethical perspectives of Israeli teachers. codes European Journal of Teacher Education, 32 (4), 473- 487. the participants discussed difficulties in defining boundary lines, and the dilemma of negotiating that line L., Williams-Johnson, M., & Schutz, P. (2009). Boundary dilemmas in teacher-student relationships: withAultman, students. struggling with the line. Teaching and Teacher Education, 25, 636-646. Figure 1. Frequency distribution (n and percentage) of the aggregated (elementary and secondary) ethical dilemmas identified by teachers. Categories Colleagues

19% Students 17% Building Administration 12% Extent of Duties 12% Policies 11% Implicit Norms 10%

Curriculum/Instruction/Assessment 9% Parents 6% Self Mentoring 0% 31% of all ethical dilemmas involve Combined licensed educators Total n =

202 5% 1% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 12% 14% 16% 18% 20% Hutchings, T. & Norris, A. (2014). Categorical domains of ethical dilemmas faced by teachers: A typology. Unpublished raw data. Without a Common Framework of DecisionMaking

Implicit norms develop within the learning community and vary by teacher grouping, administrator, school, and district. Teachers rely on a personal morality and life experiences to guide their decision-making. Teachers' roles are not clearly defined, and the extent of their duties not delineated, which results in arbitrary boundaries. There is a collegial loyalty in not reporting perceived misconduct. There is often a deference of responsibilities by teachers. Teachers often feel as though they are placed in positions of powerlessness when faced with ethical decisions that might conflict with supervisors. Hutchings, T. & Norris, A. (2014). Categorical domains of ethical dilemmas faced by teachers: A typology. Unpublished raw data. Without a Common Framework of DecisionMaking

There is a high degree of frustration among teachers regarding the variability of their actions ("We just need to be on the same page"). When seeking guidance on ethical decision-making, teachers often rely upon opinions that lead to situational, subjective, arbitrary, and inconsistent resolutions. There is a culture of silence that exists among teachers regarding ethical decision-making due to a fear of consequences. Ethical tensions exist in all facets of teachers roles. Teachers are making decisions in isolation and without transparency. Hutchings, T. & Norris, A. (2014). Categorical domains of ethical dilemmas faced by teachers: A typology. Unpublished raw data. Quantitative Research in Texas Overview of Research at UTSA Context

80 percent increase in the number of investigations opened by the Texas Education Agency into inappropriate educator-student relationships over last 8 reporting years Chang, J. (2016, Sept. 21). Cases of improper teacher student relationships hit 8- year high. Austin American-Statesman. Retrieved from http://atxne.ws/2cSvUes Overview of Research at UTSA Problem Educator sexual misconduct is woefully understudied (Shakeshaft, 2004, p. 51) (and it still is today) Shakeshaft, C. (2004). Educator sexual misconduct: A review of existing literature. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education. Retrieved from http://bit.ly/1QfW0bp Our purpose To systematically describe, explain, and perhaps predict the phenomenon of educator sexual misconduct (called inappropriate relationships with students and/or minors) in Texas

Overview of Research at UTSA Three facets 1. Collect through public information requests all Texas educator discipline agreed final orders and associated documents from 1/1/1999 through 6/30/2016. Data received. 2. Collect Texas certified educator employment data from school years 1995-1996 through 2015-2016 (and subsequent years as available). Data requested. 3. Collect Texas certified educator certification data from school years 1995-1996 though 2015-2016 (and subsequent years as available). Data requested. Preliminary Findings 2067 discipline sanctions examined spanning 2009 2014 (roughly 5.5 years) for two-thirds of the alphabet

29.1% of sanctions issued for IRWSM (inappropriate relationship with student or minor); next closest misconduct involved drug related offenses (19.4%) When combined with the offense category of sexual misconduct, (7.5%) (outside of the school or minor setting), over 36% of educator sanctions were for either IRWSM or sexual misconduct Thompson, D.P., & Robert C. (2016). Educator sexual misconduct in Texas: A review of educator discipline data, 2008-2014. Unpublished raw data. Preliminary Findings 70% of educators who engaged in IRWSM either voluntarily surrendered their certificates or had their certificates permanently revoked (IRWSM does not always mean sexual contact)

82% of educators who engaged in sexual misconduct either surrendered their certificates or had their certificates permanently revoked Complete database should be constructed by early 2017 Thompson, D.P., & Robert C. (2016). Educator sexual misconduct in Texas: A review of educator discipline data, 2008-2014. Unpublished raw data. How this Research Will Inform Backward mapping The quantitative research will permit us to describe, explain, and predict the phenomenon of IRWSM on a large-scale statewide basis Having access to the original source documents will permit us to examine each case on an individual

basis to gain a sense of the critical decision points in the case, to examine the gray areas that led to the fateful decision(s), and to apply principles of professional ethics to educator decision-making Backward Mapping our Case Study Professional Ethics Codes of Defines the Conduct Guide Decision-Making Mitigate Risks Protect the Profession Protect the Practitioner Protect Student Welfare 1000s of Daily Decisions

Emotional & Intellectual Intimacy Vulnerabilities Event Multiple Acting Stakeholders in the Public In loco parentis / Agents of Interest the State Nuanced & Complex Boundary

Possible Sanctions Power Absolutism Competing Tensions Operate within the gray . Navigate the gray . Embrace the gray (Hutchings, T. 2016) Model Code of Ethics for Educators Emotional Attachment Principle II: Responsibility for Professional Competence A (4): Accepting the responsibilities, performing duties and providing services corresponding to the area of certification, licensure, and training of ones position;

(nasdtec.ne t) Model Code of Ethics for Educators Emotional Attachment Principle III: Responsibility to Students The professional educator promotes the health, safety, and well-being of students by establishing and maintaining appropriate verbal, physical, emotional and social boundaries. A (2): Interacting with students with transparency and in appropriate settings; A (7): Avoid multiple relationships with student which might impair objectivity and increase the risk of harm to student learning or well-being, or decrease student effectiveness; (nasdtec.ne t) Model Code of Ethics for Educators

Emotional Attachment Principle V: Responsible and Ethical Use of Technology The ethical educator is vigilant to ensure appropriate boundaries of time, place and role are maintained when using electronic communication. A (1): Using social media responsibly, transparently, and primarily for purposes of teaching and learning per school and district policy. The professional professional educator considers the ramifications of using social media and direct communication via technology on ones (nasdtec.ne interactions with students, t) colleagues, and the general public;

Case Study: The Rest of the Story Texas State Board of Educator Certification brought contested case against teacher seeking to revoke her certificate for engaging in a sexual or romantic relationship with the student The administrative law judge in the case recommended that the certificate not be revoked, as the evidence demonstrated that the teacher did not have a sexual relationship with the student, and did not rise to the level (at that time) of the teacher engaging in a romantic relationship with the student (ALJ strongly suggested that the conclusion would have been different under the current code) As best as can be determined, teacher completed that school year

in the district, taught one subsequent year in another district, and then left the profession in 2007

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Pathology of Male Genital System - University of Yeditepe ...

    Pathology of Male Genital System - University of Yeditepe ...

    Pathology of Male Genital System Doç. Dr. Işın DOĞAN EKİCİ Disorders of the male genital system include: a variety of malformations, inflammatory conditions, and neoplasms involving the penis and scrotum, prostate, and testes. HYPOSPADIAS Abnormal opening of the urethra onto...
  • THE NEW GENERAL DATA PROTECTION REGULATIONS (GDPR) Malkiat

    THE NEW GENERAL DATA PROTECTION REGULATIONS (GDPR) Malkiat

    GDPR Articles 9 and 10: The GDPR requires special conditions to be met for processing "special categories" of personal data and criminal convictions data. Articles 9 and 10 of the GDPR prohibit the processing of such data unless the special...
  • Little Man Computer - UNC Asheville

    Little Man Computer - UNC Asheville

    Little Man Computer When your program gets "translated to machine code" all 0's & 1's The translator must know the language of the program (java) as well as the language of the cpu - "the instruction set" LMC is a...
  • Location-aware Query Processing and Optimization: A Tutorial Mohamed

    Location-aware Query Processing and Optimization: A Tutorial Mohamed

    Xuegang Huang and Christian S. Jensen. Towards A Streams-Based Framework for Defining Location-based Queries. In Proceedings of the International Workshop on Spatio-temporal Database Management, STDBM, pages 73-80, Toronto, Canada, August 2004. Yufei Tao, George Kollios, Jerey Considine, Feifei Li, and...
  • Populus is relevant to key DOE missions

    Populus is relevant to key DOE missions

    Toby Bradshaw University of Washington [email protected] ... high-throughput genotyping systems Transformation and mutagenesis/tagging are key enabling technologies for any model system Improve bioinformatics for comparative genomics MAY DARWIN'S GHOST SMITE US DEAD IF WE CLAIM TO BE ...
  • Reviewing SBAC Summative Assessment Results to Guide Instructional

    Reviewing SBAC Summative Assessment Results to Guide Instructional

    domain‐specific (tier 3) words, and words with multiple meanings, based on context, word relationships (e.g., synonyms), word structure (e.g., common Greek or Latin roots, affixes), or use of resources (e.g., dictionary, glossary), with primary focus on the academic vocabulary common...
  • NC Department of Health and Human Services Division

    NC Department of Health and Human Services Division

    NC-DSS is seeking a waiver that will increase participation among low income elderly persons, called the Elderly Simplified Application Project, or ESAP. If approved, the waiver will assist in providing FNS/SNAP benefits to:
  • Molecular Motors

    Molecular Motors

    Large globular heads bind and split ATP Undergo a configurational change that changes the angle of the head with respect to an a-helical tail. E.g. Myosin II Myosin II of vertebrate muscle The Myosin family portrait N-----C In vitro motility...