Canadian Constitutional Law Section B: November 19, 2011

Canadian Constitutional Law Section B: November 19, 2011

Canadian Constitutional Law Section B: November 19, 2011 Judicial Decisions on the Charter of Rights Course Director: Ian Greene Presentations: Monahan Patrick Monahan, Constitutional Law, Ch 13 (except 439-460): Manivillie Kanagasabapathy Patrick Monahan, Constitutional Law, Chapter 14: Samaneh Bayat Oakes Test for Section 1

S 1 of the Charter: The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees the rights and freedoms set out in it subject only to such reasonable limits prescribed by law as can be demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society. The Oakes test has two parts: First, the objective of the government in limiting a right must be of sufficient importance to society to justify encroachment on a right. Second (proportionality test), the limit must be reasonable and demonstrably justified in terms of not being out of proportion to the government objective, and must therefore satisfy three criteria: (a) it must be rationally connected the government objective, and not "arbitrary or capricious (rational connection test); (b) it should impair the right as little as is necessary to achieve the govern ment objective (minimal impairment test); and (c) even if all of the points above are satisfied, the effects of the limit cannot be out of proportion to what is accomplished by the government objective in other words, the cure cannot be allowed to be more harmful than the disease.

The Court and the Constitution: Leading Cases Case 22, The Queen v. Big M. Drug Mart (freedom of religion, 1985): Andrei Segal Case 24, The Queen v. Oakes (1986): Joel Montesanti Case 25, Morgentaler v. The Queen: Maggie Inrig Case 26, Quebec v. Ford et al. (Quebec sign case, 1988): Jillian Steinberg Case 28, R. v. Keegstra (hate speech, 1990): Daniel Italiano Case 31, RJR-MacDonald Inc. v. Canada (AG), (advertising, 1995): Ian Greene RJR-MacDonald (1995)

1988 federal Tobacco Products Control Act of Mulroney government challenged by tobacco companies; got to Supreme Court in 1994 Five-four decision in 1995 struck down key parts of the legislation. Majority decision of McLachlin: Purpose of Act: to prevent people in Canada from being persuaded by advertising and promotion to use tobacco products, and to discourage people who see the package from tobacco use. Sufficienty important to justify infringing Freedom of Expression No rational connection between objectives and means used; no social science evidence justifying such drastic means. Legislation does not limit Fr of Exp as little as necessary Concurring decision by Iacobucci:

The legislation passes the rational connection test, but not the minimal impairment test. To pass this test, revise legislation to prohibit lifestyle advertising & advertising directed at adolescents. Dissenting opinion of La Forest: Purpose of Act is to prevent people in Canada from being persuaded by advertising and promotion to use tobacco products, and to discourage people who see the package from tobacco use. The Act is sufficiently important to infringe rights, and given the definition of purpose, passes all three parts of Part II of the proportionality test. Emphasizes importance of deferring to Parliament regarding complex policy choices Impact of RJR Macdonald Chrtien government had Parliament enact the Tobacco Act in 1997, which permitted information and brand-preference advertising, while forbidding lifestyle advertising and promotion,

advertising appealing to young persons, and false or misleading advertising or promotion. The new legislation also increased the amount of space that would need to be taken up on packaging for health warnings was increased from 33 percent to 50 percent. The revised legislation was upheld by the Supreme Court in 2007. The Court referred to the Hogg-Bushell dialogue theory. Janet Hiebert is critical of Parliament for implementing the majoritys prescription for creating legislation relating to tobacco advertising that would comply with the Charter. See Charter Conflicts: What is Parliaments Role? (McGill-Queens Univ Press, 2002) See also Ian Greenes more extensive notes on RJR Macdonald, linked to the class web page. The Court and the Constitution: Leading Cases

Case 34, Sauv v. Canada (prisoners voting rights, 2002): Kris Stone Case 36, Chaoulli v. Quebec (AG), (right to adequate health care, 2005): Bonnie Granata Case 37, Health Services and Support (SCC overrules a previous decision and expands labour rights, 2007): Augustine Nnamdi Case 39, Delgamuukw v. BC (aboriginal land claim rights, 1997): Trisha Johnson-White Case 40, R. v. Marshall (aboriginal constitutional fishing rights, 1999): Andreia Cabral Case 48, Ref. re Secession of Quebec (principles of Canadian democracy, 1998): Neha Narang

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • The Thesis Statement - anderson.k12.ky.us

    The Thesis Statement - anderson.k12.ky.us

    The Thesis Statement Does writing a thesis statement make you feel like this? ... Sometimes this type of statement is referred to as the "plural noun" formula. General thesis statements use more general language to focus the discussion and give...
  • Presentación de PowerPoint

    Presentación de PowerPoint

    AVLIMIL 1 píldora diaria con un vaso de agua Donnacreme es un gel a base de principios activos naturales, de aplicación tópica y acción local, que se aplica en el clítoris para aumentar la sensibilidad en esta zona y facilitar...
  • Upending the Pyramid: Moving Donors to Mid Level

    Upending the Pyramid: Moving Donors to Mid Level

    cultivation . Analytical tools or models. Major & Planned . Gifts. Elevation . and . Demotion. Lead Qualification, Research, Analytics. One on One interaction "Turnstile" of cultivation, solicitation, stewardship. Can utilize elements and touch-points of the MD Prospecting Program. Influenced...
  • 5SR004 Sport and Exercise Psychology

    5SR004 Sport and Exercise Psychology

    Sport Psychology Mr Mather and Miss Desa Aims and Objectives Develop an understanding of the key principles within sport and exercise psychology Engage in learning and application of critical literature Gather and critically examine psychological data Make appropriate analysis that...
  • January 27, 2010-Teacher Quality and School Improvement in ...

    January 27, 2010-Teacher Quality and School Improvement in ...

    Teacher Quality and School Improvement in 2010: P-20 in Historical Perspective Steve Tozer, UIC [email protected] * * * * What we learned in graduate school Schools don't really affect student learning; it's SES that does.
  • The role of PMOC in modulating the deglacial

    The role of PMOC in modulating the deglacial

    During Heinrich Events, ITCZ moved southward. Changes of the ITCZ position are closely related to changes of the meridional heat transport. Regionally, the collapse of the AMOC and build-up of PMOC can induce different changes of the ITCZ position with...
  • Suicidal Behaviors Involving Prescription Drugs in Individuals 50

    Suicidal Behaviors Involving Prescription Drugs in Individuals 50

    1Rocky Mountain Poison & Drug Center - Denver Health, Denver, CO 2University of Colorado School of Medicine, Aurora, CO Introduction Results Conclusions 8,667 Intentional exposures met criteria Relationships between suicide attempts and completed suicides using prescription opioids and stimulants may...
  • Environmental Degradation and Pesticides

    Environmental Degradation and Pesticides

    Environmental Degradation and Pesticides. ... Iowa Association of Naturalists. IAN-103. 1998. In many places of the world, water is a scarce resource. People must carry it long distances in order to meet their daily needs. It may need to be...